Login / Register

Enter Your Address

ADDRESS Please enter your address
Bagel Jay's Amherst

Bagel Jay's Amherst

 
Information
Bagel Jay's Amherst

Bagel Jay's Amherst

4498 Main St., Amherst, NY 14226
 

Delicious specialty bagels, wraps, and shmears. The perfect breakfast!

Ordering Hours
Sunday8 AM - 2:15 PM
Monday8 AM - 2:15 PM
Tuesday8 AM - 2:15 PM
Wednesday8 AM - 2:15 PM
Thursday8 AM - 2:15 PM
Friday8 AM - 2:15 PM
Saturday8 AM - 2:15 PM

Oven Fresh Bagels  

The way they're supposed to be! Jay's secret recipe- New York style. Hearth baked fresh throughout the day! Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Onion, Garlic, Everything, Cinnamon Raisin, Blueberry, Pumpernickel, Tomato Pesto, vegetable, Whole Wheat, Multi Grain, Chocolate Chip, Cranberry Orange, Marble Rye, Jalapeno Cheddar, Salt, Baily, Bagel Sticks

Breakfast Special - Available All Day!
Single Bagel with Plain Shmear and a Dark Roast 12 oz Coffee
$6.69
Single Bagel
$1.89
Single Bagel with Flavored Shmear
Our Spreads are made with the finest cream cheese available. You will find plenty of hand-chopped vegetables, pure honey, strawberries and smoked salmon
$4.79
Single Bagel with Plain Shmear
$4.29
Single Bagel with Jelly
$2.79
Single Bagel with Butter or Smart Balance
$3.09
Single Bagel with PB&J
$4.29
1/2 Dozen Bagels
$9.79
Baker's Dozen Bagels
Select 13 of Your favorite bagels
$18.39
Sack of Bagels & More
Baker's Dozen with Tub of Butter and Tub of Shmear
$24.19

Baked Goods  

Cinnamon Stick
$2.49
Asiago
$2.59
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Add Butter or Smart Balance $1.60
$3.49
Triple Berry Muffin
Add Butter or Smart Balance $1.60
$3.49
Pastry Heart
$3.79
Cinnamon Twist
$3.79

All Day Egg Bagels  

Farm Fresh Favorites - All Day Long!

No. 1 Egg & Cheese Bagel
$4.59
No. 2 Egg, Ham & Cheese Bagel
$5.79
No. 3 Egg, Bacon & Cheese Bagel
$5.79
No. 3 Egg, Chicken Sausage & Cheese Bagel
$5.79

Deli Favorites  

Deli Sandwich on your choice of bagel, wheat wrap, or NY Rye, with choice of lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, hot banana peppers and alfalfa sprouts Make it a Combo- Add a beverage and side

Roasted Turkey Breast Sandwich
$8.79
Sahlen's Ham Sandwich
$8.79
Roast Beef Sandwich
$10.39
BLT Sandwich
$8.09

Jay's Classics  

Your Choice of Bagel or Wheat Wrap Make it a Combo- Add a beverage and side

Chicken Salad Bagel/Wrap
$9.49
Tuna Salad Bagel/Wrap
$8.79
Egg Salad Bagel/Wrap
$8.79
Veggie Delight Bagel/Wrap
$6.39
Hummus Bagel/Wrap
$8.09
Cheese Melt Bagel/Wrap
$4.59
Tuna Melt Bagel/Wrap
$9.49
Pizza Bagel
$6.89

Taste Tempting Specialty Bagel Sandwiches  

Make it a Combo- Add a beverage and side

The Delaware Bagel Sandwich
Roasted Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Coleslaw and Russian Dressing
$10.99
The Buffalo Club Bagel Sandwich
Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise
$10.99
Albuquerque Turkey Bagel Sandwich
Roasted Turkey, a Shmear of Red pepper Jalapeno, Lettuce and Tomato
$10.99
Athens Turkey Bagel Sandwich
Turkey Breast, Hummus with Feta, Lettuce, Tomato and a Special Dressing
$10.99
Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular Bagel Sandwich
Our classic tuna, provolone cheese, sliced black olives, special dressing, lettuce and tomato
$10.99
Hummus Spectacular Bagel Sandwich
Hummus, feta, black olives, red onion and special dressing
$10.99
The Snyder Bagel Sandwich
Sahlen's ham with scallion schmear, lettuce and tomato
$10.99
The Rueben Bagel Sandwich
Hot corned beef or roasted turkey, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing
$12.69
The Hopkins Bagel Sandwich
Hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing
$12.69
The Downtowner Bagel Sandwich
Rare roast beef, red onion, hot banana peppers and a shmear of garlic & herb
$11.49
Athens Chicken Bagel Sandwich
Marinated chicken, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato and special dressin
$11.49
Chicken Club Wrap
Marinated chicken, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato and special dressing
$11.49
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Marinated chicken breast, asiago cheese, lettuce, tomato & Caesar dressing
$11.49
The Hertel Bagel Sandwich
Turkey, ham, pepperoni, melted provolone, tomato, banana pepper and special dressing
$11.49

Salads  

Always the freshest and highest quality ingredients!

Whitefish Salad
$11.49
Cream Cheese and Nova Salad
$14.99
Greek Salad
$8.09
Caesar Salad
$8.09
Green Salad with Tuna
$10.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
$10.99
Classic Salad Plate
Choice of 2 scoops of Tuna, Egg or Chicken Salad with Lettuce Tomato, Cukes and Bagel Chips
$11.49

Sides  

Side of Potato Salad
$2.79
Side of Coleslaw
$2.79
Lay's Chips
$2.09
Baked Lay's Chips
$2.09
Doritos Chips
$2.09

Desserts  

Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.79
Chocolate Covered Macaroon
$2.79
Black & White Cookie
$4.59
Brownie
$4.59
Crumb Cake
$3.99
Pound Cake
$4.59

Soup  

Soup of the Day - Regular
$4.59
Soup of the Day - Large
$5.39
Chili - Regular
$6.89
Chili - Large
$8.09
Chili - Regular with Buttered Bagel
$8.09

Beverages  

Jake's Java
Our Finest Dark Roast. Choose Regular, Decaf or Flavored
$2.99
Iced Coffee
Select Chocolate Bianco, Caramel or Hazelnut
$3.99
Hot Chocolate
$2.99
Hot Tea
$2.99
Herbal Tea
$2.99
Cappucino
$3.59
Pepsi Fountain Beverages
Select Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Loganberry, Lipton Tea, Mountain Dew or Dr. Pepper
$2.89
Topicana Orange Juice
$4.39
Milk
Choose 1%, Chocolate or Skim
$2.29
Aquafina Water
$2.69
Java O Go Box
Includes Cream, Sugar, Stirrers and Cups
$26.49

We offer delivery for this restaurant.

Ordering Hours

Sunday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM
Monday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM
Tuesday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM
Wednesday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM
Thursday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM
Friday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM
Saturday8:00 AM - 2:15 PM

Delicious specialty bagels, wraps, and shmears. The perfect breakfast!